Muttontown Homes for Sale

    Incorporated in 1931, Muttontown is a Village within the Town of Oyster Bay. One of the many exclusive areas on the Gold Coast North Shore, Muttontown’s roots were actually steeped in sheep pasturage, hence the origins of the name. Much larger than its contemporary border communities, Muttontown occupies over 6 square miles or 4,500+ acres of pristine lands. This residential community is surrounded to the West by The Village of Brookville, to the East by the Village of Oyster Bay Cove, to the North by East Norwich and the Village of Upper Brookville.

    Muttontown is a tranquil community once home to the grand estates built by nobility and titans of industry. It was a social magnet for the elite-of-the-elite in its heyday. Today, most of these magnificent properties have either fallen into disrepair or were carved into smaller private estates, but the grandeur and majesty remains evident with an eclectic mix of architectural styles perched on lands that were once part of such famed expansive estates as Knollwood, Pen-Mor and Easton. Horse farms are an integral part of the Muttontown facade as the equestrian lovers take full advantage of the multitude of horse trails, pristine lands and natural beauty of the area. With a private police force, minutes from shopping and easy access to main roadways, the commute into Manhattan is a short 25 minutes via LIRR.

    to
     
     
     
    Search Search
    •  
    Search

    64  properties match your search;

    Save Search
    Showing 21 - 40 of 64 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4 »
    • 73 Washington Drive Woodbury, NY 10930
      $700,000
      5 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 2750.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6331660
      This stunning 5-bedroom, 2.5-bath center hall colonial offers the perfect blend of comfort and charm. Featuring quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a cozy, modern electric fireplace. This home exudes warmth and style. The semi-finished basement includes a laundry area and freestanding pellet stove. Outdoors, enjoy a two-level deck, an above-ground pool, and professionally landscaped perennial gardens on a private, wooded lot with breathtaking mountain views. Located in Cornwall Central School District, this property backs up to deeded Forever Green land for ultimate privacy. With central air, a new roof, and quick access to major highways, shopping, and dining, it’s ideal for easy living. Residents also enjoy access to Woodbury Recreation, Earl Reservoir Park, and nearby attractions like West Point, Bear Mountain, and the Heritage Trail. Don’t miss this chance to own a serene retreat with endless amenities! Additional Information: HeatingFuel:Oil Above Ground, ParkingFeatures:2 Car Attached,
      Presented By: Houlihan Lawrence Inc.  914-962-4900
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 35 Depalma Drive Woodbury, NY 10930
      $699,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 2386.00:# Square Feet
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6336334
      Presented By: MK Realty Inc  845-782-0205
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 2 First Avenue Woodbury, NY 10950
      $650,000
      Misc For Sale ML# H6316262
      LOCATION LOCATION LOCATION!! Nestled in the heart of a desirable location, this property at the corner of First Ave. and Schunnemunk Rd. is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. The house has been meticulously gutted and cleaned, ready for a new chapter. With approved zoning and ARB plans, this property is shovel-ready and primed for transformation. The approved design includes a two-story structure with a lower level and an extension, totaling a generous 4, 200 sq feet. The first story will incorporate the existing brick structure, adding a touch of charm and character to the modern design. The property has interior design and layout drawings, providing a clear vision for the future. This is more than just a plot of land; it’s a blueprint for your dream home. The location offers the best of both worlds - privacy for those who value their peace, yet convenience for easy access to local amenities. This property is not just a place to live, but a lifestyle to embrace.
      Presented By: Exit Realty Venture  845-999-3948
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 6 Carroll Drive Woodbury, NY 10930
      $640,000
      4 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 2360.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# 3580322
      Nestled on a private cul-de-sac with four homes, this stunning Mother/Daughter residence sits on a serene .74-acre lot with a beautiful wooded view. Recently updated, the home features 3 brand-new decks accessible from both the kitchen and dining area perfect for relaxing and taking in nature. The lovely eat-in kitchen boasts abundant granite countertops, bright cabinetry, and new appliances. Sunlight pours into the living and formal dining areas, creating a warm, inviting space for family and friends. Both the master and common bathrooms have been tastefully updated, and the home offers a versatile 3-season room that can function as an office or den. The home is adorned with stylish tile and trendy vinyl/laminate flooring throughout. The lower level offers its own full kitchen, generously sized bedroom, full bath, and fireplace, making it ideal for extended family or guests. A second deck off the lower level provides additional outdoor living space. Additional features include a brand-new driveway, updated heating system, recently serviced septic, and beautifully landscaped grounds. Residents also enjoy access to Woodbury’s private recreational facilities, including a pool, parks, and lake areas. This home is in a convenient commuter location, just minutes from major roadways and commuter services an hour from New York City! This is a rare opportunity to own a beautiful, updated home in a peaceful setting in Orange County Highland Mills neighborhood area. Don’t miss out-schedule your showing today!
      Presented By: Winzone Realty Inc  718-899-7000
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 7 Tufts Lane Woodbury, NY 10930
      $628,500
      4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths Sq. Ft. 2128.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6322653
      Welcome to The Highland Lake Estates. This is a nice Spacious Raised Ranch Home in fair condition in a beautiful quiet neighborhood, sitting on a nice piece of grassy land. By entering the house the first level includes a large bright Inviting dining room and Living area, following to the kitchen with sliding glass doors leading to the deck to enjoy your private yard and the tranquility of the neighborhood, three nice sized bedrooms with closets a full bathroom with access to master suite, Downstairs you will find a Large family room who offers ample space for entertainment, with extra bedrooms and other office room, a Washroom and other storage space following to the Car garage and front driveway, it’s the corner House at circle with extra privacy, just call it home! A Perfect Location with easy access to all major highways.
      Presented By: ESTMAX REALTY  845-980-1110
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 55 Pine Hill Rd Woodbury, NY 10930
      $579,000
      5 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 2020.00:# Square Feet
      Single Family For Sale ML# 800587
      Presented By: Century 21 Realty Center  845-781-8100
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 56 Jones Drive Woodbury, NY 10930
      $575,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 1746.00:# Square Feet
      Single Family For Sale ML# 800285
      Presented By: Howard Hanna Rand Realty  845-928-9691
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 56 Jones Drive Woodbury, 10930
      $575,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 1746.00:# Square Feet
      Single Family For Sale NEW ML# H800285
      Welcome to 56 Jones Drive! This ranch style home on a large corner lot features a ceramic tiled entryway, hardwood floors and a two tier deck for outdoor entertaining. The updated kitchen boasts a center island and a skylight. All of the bedrooms are on the first level, and the primary offers a half bath en suite. A cozy living room/dining room finishes the first level. On the lower finished level, there is an opportunity for an in law suite, with an office and a large full bathroom. The large family room on the lower level features a wood stove on a brick hearth. There is also a large laundry/storage room on the lower level. Step outside the walk out basement onto the two level deck which leads to a fenced in back yard area with a storage shed/workshop and a garden. An electric vehicle charger has been installed on the side of the garage for your convenience. Great commuter location close to I87, Route 17, The Woodbury Commons, Harriman Train Station and the Bus. Walk 1/3 of a mile to the Earl Reservoir (The Rez) to enjoy swimming, walking trails, dog park, playground, a pavilion and sporting fields. BuildingAreaSource: Public Records, InteriorFeatures: In-Law Floorplan, Storage, LaundryFeatures: In Basement, Laundry Room, PatioAndPorchFeatures: Covered,
      Presented By: Howard Hanna Rand Realty  845-928-9691
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 29 Olympus Rd Woodbury, NY 10930
      $569,000
      3 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths Sq. Ft. 1834.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6321657
      Perfectly designed for effortless living & ideal for entertaining. A cozy mudroom keeps things organized & leads to the heart of the home. The spacious, sunlit living room, welcomes you with its open airy feel, elegant columns transition to the sunken formal dining room, enhanced by vaulted ceilings. Both the living room & dining room offer sliders to a massive private deck. A kitchen designed with function and style boasts granite countertops, new SS appliances and an island with seating. This sought after layout offers a full bathroom and two generous size bedrooms right on the main floor. A private retreat awaits you upstairs, where the primary bedroom sits with a walk in closet & beautiful en-suite with double shower heads and jacuzzi tub! The lower level offers an additional 1182sqft of finished rec space. Here you’ll find a perfect hang out space, flex room and another full bathroom! Walk-out to the brick lay patio under the deck, and a clear level side yard. Storage galore in the 12x16 shed. This immaculate home offers endless closet space and tons of upgrades including a new central AC unit, hot water heater and oil tank. Located in Cornwall School District, with access to Woodburys Rez & pool!
      Presented By: Howard Hanna Rand Realty  845-928-9691
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 76 Pine Hill Rd Woodbury, NY 10930
      $565,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 1768.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6320602
      Beautifully maintained home in a prime area of Woodbury. Use of town recreational facilities including lake, tennis, ball fields and basketball as well as idyllic walking paths. Close to highways and world class shopping at Woodbury Commons Enclosed deck for seasonal dining overlooks a beautiful yard where nature abounds. This home is waiting for your family. Questions??
      Presented By: ARC Realty 1 in Sales  845-783-5145
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 7 Columbia Circle Woodbury, NY 10930
      $559,000
      4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths Sq. Ft. 1884.00:# Square Feet
      Single Family For Sale ML# 800450
      Presented By: MK Realty Inc  845-782-0205
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 234 Ridge Rd Woodbury, NY 10930
      $550,000
      3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 1464.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6336043
      Step into a world of elevated design and craftsmanship with this stunning home, where every detail has been thoughtfully curated and meticulously executed. From the moment you enter, you’ll appreciate the bright, open floor plan that blends everyday living with spaces perfect for entertaining. Natural light pours in through large windows, filling each room with warmth and joy. The refinished hardwood floors, custom wood kitchen with gorgeous countertops, a spacious island, and built-in features designed by a true master-craftsman create a sense of timeless elegance. The kitchen is a true highlight, equipped with ss appliances, under-counter lighting, and a skylight that bathes the space in even more natural light. Just off the kitchen, a dream-worthy 3-season screened-in sunroom offers the perfect retreat for meals with views of your private backyard oasis, multi-level deck, and a raised-bed garden ready to grow your own vegetables and fruits. With three spacious bedrooms each with refinished hardwood floors and ample space for King- and Queen-sized beds the home offers a serene, restful retreat. The custom bathroom renovation adds a few surprises with a deep medicine cabinet hidden behind a picture, a hidden built-in hamper, and a stunning double vanity. The lower level features a beautiful family room with an updated half bath (2018), a charming laundry room with handmade pine counters (2022), and all the modern conveniences you could need, including an upgraded 200-amp electric(2016) and a high-end HE System-2000 boiler for heating and hot water. Outside, the home is equally impressive, with a detached three-car garage featuring new roof (2024), remote doors, air hoses, and a compressor (negotiable). Professionally landscaped grounds include a privacy tree line along the side yard, new walkways, and elegant uplighting (2020). More updates include a new roof and skylights (2017), multi-level decks and a pergola (2017), a huge new driveway (2015), and a new front entry door (2014), ensuring this home is not only beautifully designed but also well-maintained and move-in ready. Whether you’re looking for a quiet retreat or a place to entertain, this home offers the perfect blend of functionality and beauty. Monroe Woodbury Schools with a less than 5-minute walk to the Woodbury Earl Reservoir. The Village of Woodbury offers a Town Pool, Reservoir that has a Beach, lake for swimming, fishing and boating, plus playgrounds too! Close to All shops and Highways Additional Information: HeatingFuel:Oil Above Ground, ParkingFeatures:3 Car Detached,
      Presented By: Weichert Realtors  845-782-4646
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 10 Hollis Street Woodbury, NY 10930
      $499,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 1840.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6327431
      Better than new Side Hall Colonial with wrap around porch, lovingly renovated & upgraded thoroughly with an addition, featuring sitting room/ parlor, pocket doors, Bay window, and cherry hard wood floors. Original woodwork and trim have been refinished. Owners have upgraded electrical and plumbing systems as well as insulation and upgraded windows. Additionally C/A, upgraded natural gas fired boiler heating system has been added. This home offers a double lot and detached 2 car/ Garage/ Barn & professional Workshop WITH 220 v POWER. Double lot is partially fenced with beautiful perennial gardens and plantings. Convenient proximity to the town pool, Highland Mills town park & beach. Thruway entrance, Harriman Railway Station & Metro North to NYC, only a few miles south near the Woodbury Commons shopping center. Harriman State Park, offers numerous lakes and hiking trails for all. Various stores, services & numerous food shopping centers are also conveniently located in the area.
      Presented By: Tuxedo Park Aff Realty Ltd  845-351-4800
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 23 Woodland Rd Woodbury, NY 10930
      $475,000
      3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath Sq. Ft. 1328.00:# Square Feet
      Single Family For Sale ML# 800449
      Presented By: MK Realty Inc  845-782-0205
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 578 State Route 32 Woodbury, NY 10930
      $472,250
      Office Commercial ML# H6314336
      An exceptional opportunity awaits with this prime commercial office building located on Route 32 in Highland Mills, NY. The seller is highly motivated and is relocating to another facility, offering a unique chance for the right buyer. The seller is also open to a rent-back arrangement, making this property a flexible investment. Situated on the bustling Route 32, this property boasts high visibility and easy access, ideal for attracting clients and customers. It is just minutes away from the renowned Woodbury Commons Premium Outlets. The office building is conveniently close to public transportation, making it an attractive location for employees and clients. Easy connectivity to major highways ensures smooth commutes and logistics. The building offers a versatile layout suitable for a variety of businesses, from professional offices to retail spaces. The interior is well-maintained with ample natural light, providing a comfortable and productive working environment. Ample parking space is available on-site, accommodating both staff and visitors comfortably. Close to dining, shopping, and other essential services, this location ensures convenience for your team and clients. With a motivated seller and the option for rent-back, this property presents a lucrative investment opportunity for savvy investors. Don’t miss out on this prime commercial real estate opportunity in Highland Mills. Contact us today to schedule a viewing. This is a rare opportunity to secure a prime commercial property in a thriving area. Act now and take advantage of this motivated seller’s offer!
      Presented By: Compass Greater NY, LLC  845-236-6170
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 271 and 231 Smith Clove Rd Woodbury, NY 10930
      $450,000
      Misc For Sale ML# H6333091
      This beautiful 25 acre parcel in the Town of Woodbury is now available for sale! Currently, it is zoned as farm land. The owner has grown crops on a portion of the land for the past 7 or 8 years, with no pesticides. It is located in a beautiful spot, convenient to the highway, and about an hour from New York City. The view is outstanding! The land is level, and overlooks the surrounding mountains. Across the street, the property is owned by West Point and will not be developed. You’re not a farmer, but love the view? The best alternate use for the next owner might be for a single family home. Please note this sale includes 2 lots 218-2-53 (11.6 acres) and 218-2-49 (14 acres). Please do not go on the property unaccompanied! CurrentUses: Single Family,
      Presented By: HomeSmart Homes & Estates  845-547-0005
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 241 Smith Clove Rd Woodbury, NY 10930
      $450,000
      1 Bedroom 1 Full Bath Sq. Ft. 1000.00:#
      Single Family For Sale ML# H6333089
      What a view! Charming cottage style home located on 1.5 private acres is adjacent to open land and has splendid views of the surrounding mountains! Just an hour or so from New York City, this is a perfect spot for your weekend getaway. Or make it your new home! The house is in the Monroe Woodbury school district and includes the coveted Woodbury Recreation the John Burke Memorial Pool, also the Park at the Rez fishing, swimming, PICKLE BALL, soccer, sensory park and more. The updated home features an open floor plan. The living room has vaulted ceilings, a gorgeous gas fireplace and windows galore, bringing in natural light and views of the beauty of nature that surrounds. The kitchen has stainless appliances and a farmhouse sink. Large bedroom has French doors leading out to the yard. Updated bathroom has walk in shower. The spacious loft is a perfect for additional sleeping area or a home office. The level property is private, with mature fruit trees. It has a circular driveway and includes a shed. Easy access to NYS Thruway, and NYC bus or train. Close to Woodbury Commons, shops and restaurants. Make this cute house in Woodbury your next home! ConstructionDescription: Vinyl Siding,
      Presented By: HomeSmart Homes & Estates  845-547-0005
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 27 Butternut Court Woodbury, NY 10930
      $415,000
      2 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths Sq. Ft. 1380.00:#
      Townhouse For Sale ML# H6321622
      Welcome to your dream home! This property boasts a warm and inviting fireplace, perfect for cozy evenings. The kitchen is a chef’s delight featuring an accent backsplash and all stainless steel appliances, sure to inspire your culinary creativity. Recent improvements include partial flooring replacement and a fresh coat of interior paint, adding a modern touch to the home. This property is a perfect blend of comfort and style, and it awaits its new owner. Don’t miss out on this gem!
      Presented By: Opendoor Brokerage LLC  480-462-5392
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 8 Apisson Trail Woodbury, NY 10930
      $400,000
      Misc For Sale ML# 800647
      Presented By: RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group  845-565-0004
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    • 10 Falkirk Avenue Woodbury, NY 10917
      $449,000
      $399,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths Sq. Ft. 1134.00:#
      Single Family For Sale PRICE REDUCED ML# H6335253
      MOTIVATED SELLER: This charming three bedroom, two full bath home is situated on a quiet dead end street, giving you the perfect balance of charm and convenience. The main level offers a kitchen, a full bathroom, a living room, as well as a dining room that opens up to a large three season wrap around porch. Upstairs are three bedrooms and another full-size bathroom. Outside enjoy a private backyard with a patio, perfect for entertaining or relaxing outdoors. Conveniently located close to schools, shopping, major highways and public transportation, offering the best of both worlds - peaceful living with easy access to all the amenities you need. Come and take a look today and make this your new home! Additional Information: HeatingFuel:Oil Above Ground,
      Presented By: Exit Realty Venture  845-999-3948
      Call Today: 516-978-9393, 516-626--1500, or  Email: Donnamarie Chaimanis
    Showing 21 - 40 of 64 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4 »
    OneKeyâ„¢ MLS The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the OneKeyâ„¢ MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than GoldCoastLuxuryLife are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.

    Questions? Just Ask!

    Submit